WMM vs. WBM Roads: Key Differences and Applications | Civil Works and Solutions

 Rigid pavements, often called concrete roads, are a preferred choice for engineers due to their superior quality and strength. They are designed to distribute loads over a wide area, unlike flexible pavements, which transfer loads through grain-to-grain contact. This characteristic allows rigid pavements to withstand high traffic volume and heavy traffic loads because of their inherent flexural strength.

Definition and Core Characteristics

A rigid pavement is primarily made of Portland Cement Concrete (PCC) and exhibits high flexural strength and stiffness. The stresses in these pavements are transferred through slab action, meaning the concrete slab itself acts as a structural element that spreads the vehicle loads over a large area of the subgrade. The deflection of rigid pavements is very small, hence the term "rigid".

Source: Unsplash

While the initial cost of constructing rigid pavements is high, their overall cost over the design life, including maintenance, is considered quite economical. They require the highest level of quality control at all construction stages to achieve the designed strength. In India, concrete roads are built according to provisions in IRC codes, such as IRC:15-2002 for standard specifications, IRC:61-1976 for hot weather construction, and IRC:91-1985 for cold weather construction.

Structure and Components of Rigid Pavement

Rigid pavements typically consist of several layers, each serving a specific function to ensure durability and longevity. The main components include:

Layer	Description	Key Functions
Concrete Slab (Surface Course)	The main structural layer, made of Portland Cement Concrete (PCC), typically 150–300 mm thick. It can be plain, reinforced, or prestressed. For heavy traffic, IRC advises an M-40 cement concrete mix with a minimum flexural strength of 45 kg/cm².	Directly withstands vehicle loads and provides skid resistance. Its water resistance prevents water penetration into underlying layers.
Base Course	An optional layer constructed with high-quality aggregates or dry lean concrete (DLC), positioned below the concrete slab. A minimum thickness of 100 mm is recommended.	Provides additional load support and a solid foundation. For heavy traffic, dry lean concrete is preferred for its uniform support and high K-value.
Subbase Course (Granular Subbase - GSB)	A layer of granular or stabilized material placed beneath the concrete slab to provide uniform support. Materials can include factory aggregates, granular fill, crushed rock, recycled concrete, or crushed brick. Lower quality aggregates than the base course, but higher quality than subgrade soil.	Reduces the overall construction cost by allowing for a reduced design thickness of the concrete slab. Serves as a drainage layer to prevent moisture accumulation and frost effects. Supports upper layers, controls frost action, and prevents fines from the subgrade from infiltrating the surface layers.
Subgrade	The natural soil layer at the bottom, which is prepared and compacted to support the entire pavement structure and traffic loads.	Ultimately supports all subsequent pavement layers and traffic loads. Its quality and compaction are crucial for the pavement's long service life.
Joints	Essential components that allow for movement and control cracking. Types include: Expansion Joints (allow thermal expansion), Contraction Joints (control cracking due to shrinkage), and Construction Joints (used where concrete placement is interrupted).	Manage stresses from drying shrinkage, temperature variations, and traffic loads. They are typically filled with sealants and may use dowel bars for load transfer or tie bars to prevent lane separation.
Reinforcement	Steel bars or mesh (optional) used in reinforced concrete pavements, particularly in JRCP and CRCP.	Primarily used to control crack widths and spacing, and improve load transfer, rather than for structural strengthening of the slab itself.

Types of Rigid Pavement

Different types of rigid pavements are characterized by their jointing and reinforcement methods, which control forces like drying shrinkage, environmental changes, and traffic loads. The two types commonly used in Texas are Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavement (CRCP) and Concrete Pavement Contraction Design (CPCD), also known as Jointed Concrete Pavement (JCP).

• Jointed Plain Concrete Pavement (JPCP):

  • This type does not include steel reinforcement and relies on regularly spaced transverse contraction joints to control cracking.
  • It is often the most common type due to its cost-effectiveness and ease of construction.
  • Load transfer at transverse joints in JPCP is typically facilitated by smooth dowel bars.

• Jointed Reinforced Concrete Pavement (JRCP):

  • Similar to JPCP, but it includes steel reinforcement within the concrete slabs.
  • The reinforcement allows for fewer transverse joints because it helps control cracking and enhances the overall strength of the pavement.
  • JRCP is often used in areas with heavy truck or wheel loads. The steel reinforcement here is meant to control crack width rather than providing structural strength.

• Continuously Reinforced Concrete Pavement (CRCP):

  • Characterized by continuous steel reinforcement throughout the entire pavement section, with no transverse joints except at structures or construction joints.
  • The continuous longitudinal steel's function is to control concrete volume changes due to temperature and moisture and keep transverse cracks tightly closed. Transverse steel keeps longitudinal joints and cracks closed.
  • CRCP is commonly used for highways and roads with heavy traffic loads as it eliminates the need for joint maintenance and reduces the potential for faulting and pumping. In Texas, CRCP is the preferred type for new or reconstructed rigid pavements.

• Prestressed Concrete Pavement (PCP):

  • This type uses prestressing techniques to reduce tensile stresses and cracking, thereby enhancing performance and crack control.

Construction Process of Rigid Pavements

The construction of rigid pavements involves several critical steps that demand high-level quality control.

1. Preparation of Subgrade: The subgrade is thoroughly cleaned, shaped, leveled, and compacted according to the design camber and gradient. Weak spots must be eliminated to ensure uniform strength. If no base layer is provided, the subgrade should be watered for 6-20 hours before concrete placement to prevent water seepage from the mix.
2. Provision of Subbase Course: A subbase is provided if the subgrade is not adequate, or to reduce construction costs by allowing a thinner concrete slab. The subbase material is laid and compacted.
3. Placing of Forms: Forms, made of timber or mild steel channel sections, are securely fixed to the ground with depth equal to the concrete slab design depth. They must be firm enough to support the concrete pour and checked for line and grading, and oiled from the inside.
4. Watering: After formwork, the base or subgrade should be wet at least 12 hours before concrete placement, ensuring no standing water. This step can be skipped if the surface is covered with a waterproof insulating layer.
5. Batching and Mixing of Materials: Proportioned ingredients are precisely weighed in a weight-batching plant and fed into a hopper with the appropriate cement quantity. Materials are mixed dry in a concrete mixer, with water added last according to the water-cement ratio.
6. Transporting and Placing of Concrete: The concrete mix is rapidly transported to the site and deposited in layers no more than 50mm-80mm thick, or 2-3 times the aggregate size (whichever is greater). The entire bay must be filled thoroughly in successive batches as a continuous operation. Voids are eliminated by roding and vibrating the mix. For reinforced slabs, concrete is placed in two stages: first up to the reinforcement layer, then reinforcement is placed, and the remaining depth is filled and compacted.
7. Compacting the Concrete Slab: After placing, the slab is compacted using a tamper fitted with handles, heavy screed, power-driven finishing machine, or vibrating hand screeds. Immersion vibrators are used for greater depths.
8. Floating: The entire slab surface is floated with wooden flat boards to provide an even surface free of corrugations.
9. Belting: To enhance skid and slip resistance, belting is done after floating, just before the concrete hardens. This step is optional.
10. Brooming and Edging: The surface is broomed at right angles to the road's centerline from edge to edge using drawing brushes. Edging is done on the sides before the concrete sets for finished edges.
11. Curing: The concrete slab must be kept moist during the hardening period, checking regularly for water loss. Initial curing lasts 24 hours, after which wet mats are removed for a final curing period of 2-3 weeks. Methods include ponding, covering with wet sand/earth, or spraying chemicals like sodium or calcium chloride. Proper curing is crucial to avoid early-age cracking.
12. Joint Cutting and Sealing: Joints are sawed into the concrete slab to control cracking caused by temperature and shrinkage. These joints are then sealed.
13. Opening to Traffic: The concrete slab is opened to traffic once it attains the specified strength, typically after 28 days of curing.

Design Considerations

Rigid pavement design involves complex factors to ensure long-term performance and durability. Key considerations include:

• Flexural Strength: Slabs must be designed to withstand flexural stresses from wheel loads and temperature changes.
• Joints: Proper spacing and design of expansion, contraction, and construction joints are essential to control cracking and accommodate thermal expansion and contraction.
• Drainage: Effective drainage systems are critical to prevent water accumulation beneath the slab, which can lead to pumping, erosion, and frost damage. Permeable bases and subdrain systems are often incorporated.
• Thickness: Determined based on anticipated traffic loads and subgrade conditions. The AASHTO 1993 Method uses empirical equations, considering factors like traffic loading (18-kip Equivalent Single Axle Loads - ESALs), modulus of subgrade reaction, slab thickness, concrete strength, reliability, and standard deviation to calculate required slab thickness.
• Modulus of Subgrade Reaction (k): This value estimates the support provided by the layers below the concrete slab. It is determined by field plate-bearing tests or correlation with other tests.
• Reinforcement: The amount and placement of steel reinforcement (in JRCP and CRCP) are based on anticipated stresses and crack control needs. Longitudinal steel in CRCP is for controlling concrete volume changes and keeping transverse cracks tightly closed, not primarily for strengthening the slab.
• Environmental Factors: Temperature differentials between the top and bottom of the slab cause warping stresses, and seasonal variations lead to frictional stresses, both of which must be accounted for in design. Critical stress combinations can occur at different times of day and seasons (e.g., summer mid-day, winter mid-day, mid-nights).
• Design Period: Rigid pavements are typically designed for a performance period of 30 years.
• Fatigue Analysis: The design process includes checking for cumulative fatigue damage due to repeated axle loads and temperature cycles, especially for Top-Down Cracking (TDC) and Bottom-Up Cracking (BUC).

Advantages of Rigid Pavement

Rigid pavements offer significant benefits for long-term infrastructure projects:

• Durability and Long Service Life: They are highly durable and can last for 25–40 years or more with minimal maintenance, resisting weathering and heavy traffic loads.
• Low Maintenance: They require less frequent repairs compared to flexible pavements, as they are less susceptible to issues like rutting, leading to lower maintenance costs.
• High Strength and Load Distribution: Their rigid nature and slab action allow them to distribute heavy loads over a wide area, minimizing stress on the subgrade and preventing excessive surface deformations.
• Resistance to Oils and Chemicals: Concrete is generally unaffected by fuel spills, making it suitable for industrial and airport settings.
• Reflectivity: The light-colored surface of concrete improves nighttime visibility.
• Smooth Ride Quality: They provide a smoother and more comfortable ride for vehicles.
• Stiffness: Minimal deflections under traffic loads reduce rolling resistance, which can improve fuel efficiency.
• Recycling Potential: Concrete pavements can be recycled at the end of their service life, reducing waste.
• Tolerance for Subgrades: Can be constructed over poor subgrades.

Disadvantages and Challenges of Rigid Pavement

Despite their advantages, rigid pavements also present certain drawbacks and challenges:

• High Initial Cost: They are generally more expensive to construct than flexible pavements due to material costs (concrete, reinforcement) and specialized construction techniques.
• Longer Construction Time: Rigid pavements require a curing period before they can be opened to traffic, leading to longer construction durations.
• Complex and Costly Repairs: Repairing damaged sections often involves removing and replacing entire concrete slabs, which is labor-intensive, more complex, and more expensive. Repairs may also require extended curing times, causing prolonged traffic disruption.
• Susceptibility to Cracking: Despite jointing, they can still be susceptible to cracking from significant temperature changes and heavy loads if not properly designed or constructed.
• Drainage Sensitivity: Poor drainage can lead to early failures, such as erosion and pumping.
• Noise Generation: Rigid pavements can generate higher tire-pavement noise, especially at higher speeds, compared to flexible pavements.
• Lack of Flexibility: Their rigid nature limits their ability to accommodate minor ground movements or settlements, which can lead to cracking or uneven settlement in areas with expansive soils.
• Environmental Impact: The production of concrete has a higher carbon footprint than asphalt, although this can be mitigated by using recycled materials.

Applications

Rigid pavements are ideally suited for applications where durability, strength, and load-carrying capacity are paramount:

• Highways and Expressways
• Airport Runways and Taxiways
• Industrial Roads and Areas
• Urban Roads with Heavy Traffic Volumes
• Parking Lots
• Bus Terminals

Recent Innovations

Advances in rigid pavement technology aim to improve construction efficiency and performance:

• Roller Compacted Concrete (RCC): Offers faster construction with reduced costs.
• Fiber-Reinforced Concrete: Enhances durability and crack resistance.
• Precast Concrete Pavement Systems (PCPS): Involve modular slabs for rapid installation, which can significantly reduce construction time.
• AASHTO Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide (MEPDG): Provides a more advanced and accurate design framework by incorporating material properties, traffic loads, environmental conditions, and performance models.